Passed along in email ... a T-shirt I want for my birthday next month:
Saturday, February 7, 2015
oh shit!
China's authorities have seized 7,600 toilet rolls and 20,000 packets of tissue printed with the image of Hong Kong chief executive CY Leung.Hong Kong's Democratic Party, which had planned to sell the novelty items at a fair next week, called the seizure a violation of freedom of expression.The tissues were confiscated from a factory in mainland China on Friday
Smokey the Bear journalism
| Unlikely thieves? |
Yesterday, on the car radio, I listened to part of an interview with a couple who were part of the eight-person team who planned meticulously and then executed the theft of FBI documents. Here's the entire interview.Before Edward Snowden, there was the Citizens’ Commission to Investigate the FBI. In 1971, eight anti-war activists broke into the FBI office in Media, Pennsylvania. Among them were John and Bonnie Raines frequent anti-war protesters and the parents of three kids.
There was something uplifting about the thoughtful, moral positions they took. In hindsight, their efforts are burnished and patriotic in the best sense of the word. But at no time during the part of the interview I heard did either husband or wife play the righteousness card. What they did was what they did. They took responsibility then (making arrangements to have someone take the kids if they got caught, eg.) and they take responsibility now. And there was something upright and thoughtful in their delivery. Sure, they were activists, but that was their responsibility. If they want my applause, I will certainly give it, but I have a hunch they are not on the applause-o-meter circuit.
One small snippet of the interview hangs in my mind like a case of bad breath. After the theft, they offered the stolen documents to three newspapers -- the Washington Post, the Los Angeles Times and the New York Times. Each newspaper faced a quandary: What do you do with stolen documents even when they are clearly real? I can't remember, but I think the 1971 break-in, theft and subsequent offering to news outlets may have been the first.
Only the Washington Post decided to run with the ball -- and that against the advice of counsel. The other two, either by their own judgment or by a judgment based on the government's phone calls hollering "stop the presses," did not... until after the Washington Post took the plunge.
And as I listened to the radio, it occurred to me, not for the first time, that the New York Times with all of its thoroughness and care and accolades, really was a practitioner of Smokey The Bear journalism ... informative, perhaps, but unwilling to protect a nation it claimed to serve. I have seen its sonorous cadences in other instances (relegating questioners of Israel's activities to lesser roles in the hierarchy of news stories on tap, eg.) and can't help being irritated by the righteousness passed off as objectivity. On balance, the newspaper may do more good than harm ... but the parental, quasi-cuddling stop-forest-fires approach sticks in my craw.
Smokey knows best.
"expert opinion"
I suppose there are greater oxymorons, but one that danced into my mind this morning was "expert opinion." The importance of the contradictory nature does not lie in the parsing and dissecting and explaining of the two words. It lies in the laziness of the one who may use them in conjunction and then rests on their implications.
Mark Twain defined and expert as "an ordinary fellow from another town" and Will Rogers seems to have been on approximately the same frequency when he defined an expert as "a man fifty miles from home with a briefcase."
And of "opinion," Twain wrote: "Mind is plainly an ass, but it will be many ages before it finds it out, no doubt. Why do we respect the opinions of any man or any microbe that ever lived? I swear [I] don't know. Why do I respect my own? Well -- that is different."
Buddha was an expert. Jesus was an expert. Einstein was an expert. News organizations feel they have done their readers a good turn when citing the expertise of others. And perhaps Twain and Rogers are experts. The realms of "expert opinion" are endless.
Check it out. Read your own laundry list of those who live fifty miles from home, whose expertise is damn near flawless, and, more important, less assailable than your own. If an expert says what I say or I agree with what an expert says, my own expertise may rise in the eyes of others but also -- and this is the sticky wicket part -- in my own.
I sort of dislike bringing the topic up because I think that the moment "expert opinion" is brought into question, there is a subtle or gross defensive effort to escape the lash. The mind fidgets and fusses and runs hither and yon in an attempt to justify and explain and reshape my reliance on figures or positions I consider reliable ... most of them fifty miles or more from home. It feels like an attack, whereas I prefer to think of it as a reminder.
And what it reminds me of is my own damned laziness. Obviously I can't know everything and can't investigate everything and can't be an expert about everything, so why should I NOT rely on the actions and words of the man or woman fifty miles from home? If I didn't have my opinions, how could I know who I was?
But is this true or is it simply an extension of my comfort-zone laziness? That's just a question, not an accusation or some tch-tch, über-moralistic critique.
Among the Internet dictionary definitions of "opinion" was one I thought was pretty good and pretty nervy: "belief stronger than impression and less strong than positive knowledge." For some, I think, there comes a time when positive knowledge (based, I assume, on experience) becomes more insistently desirable as a mode of living and being.
Put less delicately, I get sick of my bullshit, expert and otherwise. And I am willing to do the work and sweat the sweat and suffer the lash of loneliness that comes calling when honest investigation kicks in? Hey man, take it easy -- I've got kids to raise, dishes to wash and a job to hold down!
The object of all this written re-chewed cud is not to suggest that "opinion," expert or otherwise, is off the charts -- stupid as well as foolish. My view is that everyone has his or her opinions. Like sex, everybody has one and there's nothing wrong or even particularly idiotic about it. Getting rid of opinions by means of some gushing and idealistic effort is a ludicrous waste of time. And that goes double for taking the counsel of those who may currently qualify as holding "expert opinions." Relativism, like absolutism, is a lazy man's game.
But to my way of thinking, it makes some sense to loosen the reins on expertise and opinion. Both may be par for the human course, but that doesn't mean I will be well-served by relaxing and lolling in their precincts. The trick, I think, lies in taking responsibility: I am responsible. Buddha, Jesus and Einstein may offer good pointers -- pointers worth attending to from where I sit. But if I am unwilling to investigate the taste of their tea, how can I possibly lay claim to knowing what tea actually tastes like? How can I be happy?
Yes, some people strike me as being pretty smart, pretty well-versed, pretty deserving of the laurels I see fit to dole out. Mark Twain and Will Rogers are two of them. I cannot disdain a wisdom that may seem greater than my own.
But to rest, like some news reporter, on the words of an "expert" strikes me as going too far. I'll do what I can to take responsibility for the wisdom I attribute to those who live fifty miles from home.
And that's my expert opinion.
Mark Twain defined and expert as "an ordinary fellow from another town" and Will Rogers seems to have been on approximately the same frequency when he defined an expert as "a man fifty miles from home with a briefcase."
And of "opinion," Twain wrote: "Mind is plainly an ass, but it will be many ages before it finds it out, no doubt. Why do we respect the opinions of any man or any microbe that ever lived? I swear [I] don't know. Why do I respect my own? Well -- that is different."
Buddha was an expert. Jesus was an expert. Einstein was an expert. News organizations feel they have done their readers a good turn when citing the expertise of others. And perhaps Twain and Rogers are experts. The realms of "expert opinion" are endless.
Check it out. Read your own laundry list of those who live fifty miles from home, whose expertise is damn near flawless, and, more important, less assailable than your own. If an expert says what I say or I agree with what an expert says, my own expertise may rise in the eyes of others but also -- and this is the sticky wicket part -- in my own.
I sort of dislike bringing the topic up because I think that the moment "expert opinion" is brought into question, there is a subtle or gross defensive effort to escape the lash. The mind fidgets and fusses and runs hither and yon in an attempt to justify and explain and reshape my reliance on figures or positions I consider reliable ... most of them fifty miles or more from home. It feels like an attack, whereas I prefer to think of it as a reminder.
And what it reminds me of is my own damned laziness. Obviously I can't know everything and can't investigate everything and can't be an expert about everything, so why should I NOT rely on the actions and words of the man or woman fifty miles from home? If I didn't have my opinions, how could I know who I was?
The trouble arises when the question is put somewhat differently: If I did -- as I do -- have my opinions, how could I know who I am? Or, as Twain put it, "Loyalty to a petrified opinion never yet broke a
chain or freed a human soul." Part of the devoted fidgeting and fussing that goes on in the mind when it comes to "expert opinion" lies exactly here -- in proving somehow that my opinions are not petrified: Look ma! I'm a loosey-goosey free-thinker willing to list to and digest and revise all my opinions, even the expert ones. So compassionate, dontcha know!
But is this true or is it simply an extension of my comfort-zone laziness? That's just a question, not an accusation or some tch-tch, über-moralistic critique.
Among the Internet dictionary definitions of "opinion" was one I thought was pretty good and pretty nervy: "belief stronger than impression and less strong than positive knowledge." For some, I think, there comes a time when positive knowledge (based, I assume, on experience) becomes more insistently desirable as a mode of living and being.
Put less delicately, I get sick of my bullshit, expert and otherwise. And I am willing to do the work and sweat the sweat and suffer the lash of loneliness that comes calling when honest investigation kicks in? Hey man, take it easy -- I've got kids to raise, dishes to wash and a job to hold down!
The object of all this written re-chewed cud is not to suggest that "opinion," expert or otherwise, is off the charts -- stupid as well as foolish. My view is that everyone has his or her opinions. Like sex, everybody has one and there's nothing wrong or even particularly idiotic about it. Getting rid of opinions by means of some gushing and idealistic effort is a ludicrous waste of time. And that goes double for taking the counsel of those who may currently qualify as holding "expert opinions." Relativism, like absolutism, is a lazy man's game.
But to my way of thinking, it makes some sense to loosen the reins on expertise and opinion. Both may be par for the human course, but that doesn't mean I will be well-served by relaxing and lolling in their precincts. The trick, I think, lies in taking responsibility: I am responsible. Buddha, Jesus and Einstein may offer good pointers -- pointers worth attending to from where I sit. But if I am unwilling to investigate the taste of their tea, how can I possibly lay claim to knowing what tea actually tastes like? How can I be happy?
Yes, some people strike me as being pretty smart, pretty well-versed, pretty deserving of the laurels I see fit to dole out. Mark Twain and Will Rogers are two of them. I cannot disdain a wisdom that may seem greater than my own.
But to rest, like some news reporter, on the words of an "expert" strikes me as going too far. I'll do what I can to take responsibility for the wisdom I attribute to those who live fifty miles from home.
And that's my expert opinion.
Friday, February 6, 2015
snorting chocolate
Passed along in email:
BRUGES, Belgium (Reuters) - When Belgian chocolatier Dominique Persoone created a chocolate-sniffing device for a Rolling Stones party in 2007, he never imagined demand would stretch much beyond the rock 'n' roll scene. But, seven years later, he has sold 25,000 of them.Inspired by a device his grandfather used to propel tobacco snuff up his nose, Persoone created a 'Chocolate Shooter' to deliver a hit of Dominican Republic or Peruvian cocoa powder, mixed with mint and either ginger or raspberry.
a "not dead" mummy
A mummified monk found preserved in Mongolia last week has been baffling and astounding those who uncovered him.Senior Buddhists say the monk, found sitting in the lotus position, is in a deep meditative trance and not dead.
too scared to relax
As a newspaper reporter in a time when people read newspapers, there would be days on which I would be responsible for some locally-big, page-one news story. The story would be "breaking," meaning that aspects and results would be continuing even as the reporter wrote the story and met the deadline that cut off additional information: The paper needed to be wrapped up and shipped off to customers.
The nearer the deadline, the greater the stress. Sometimes calculations came down to minutes: Gather as much information as possible, return to the office and write the story with the city editor (the person charged with overseeing the resulting article) breathing down your neck.
Over time, I learned a little of how to handle the three-minute, page-one story: Gather the information at the accident scene or fire or political bombshell; return to the office; check the clock and then, with under five minutes to go before deadline, GET A CUP OF COFFEE and only then sit down and start typing furiously.
A typewriter was a hand-operated machine that preceded the alleged efficiency of the computer. In the newsroom, its use was almost invariably accompanied by a cup of coffee or surreptitious scotch, cigarette and cigar smoke in the air, and some loud and choice cussing. Writing a breaking story was pedal-to-the-metal work -- a furious dash to any breaking-news finish.
The story never was perfect and yet reporters often strove for perfection -- a complete and balanced and coherent story -- over and over again. Some were better than others. Whatever the success, it always implied failure: Human stories are never complete and words cannot ever truly convey them.
But within those parameters, diversion was crucial to the quality and coherence of the story ... a rest period in which the mental muscles relaxed. Three minutes to deadline? Take at least one for a cup of really bad office coffee.
Rest and relaxation may be anathema to work/money-addicted employers intent on squeezing every last drop of 'productivity' out of employees, but where they cannot factor in the literal financial benefits of relaxation, I think they are falling down on their job.
Now, it seems, Japan, a nation full of workaholics, is considering making a law that would compel employers to make sure their workers take vacation days and otherwise unwind.
In Zen Buddhism, there is a saying: "A day without work is a day without eating." At a mundane level, this is a stab at the heart of social conscience, a quid pro quo of individual and social existence. Eating, obviously, is crucial to life. But without examining what it is that constitutes "work," how could anyone be other than a candidate for the ulcer farm putting out a mediocre product? How could anyone adequately know what work is if s/he didn't likewise know what relaxation was? Isn't this a package deal -- the one tending on the other? Could the richness of spiritual life be much more than a mediocre bluff if there were no ability to live comfortably in a world that ignored what passes for spiritual endeavor?
Sure, there are listless, lazy fuck-offs in any endeavor, but I'm not sure which is more debilitating to success -- the laziness that seeks to skirt the effort required for honest reward or the lock-step fire and brimstone of 'productivity.'
The nearer the deadline, the greater the stress. Sometimes calculations came down to minutes: Gather as much information as possible, return to the office and write the story with the city editor (the person charged with overseeing the resulting article) breathing down your neck.
Over time, I learned a little of how to handle the three-minute, page-one story: Gather the information at the accident scene or fire or political bombshell; return to the office; check the clock and then, with under five minutes to go before deadline, GET A CUP OF COFFEE and only then sit down and start typing furiously.
A typewriter was a hand-operated machine that preceded the alleged efficiency of the computer. In the newsroom, its use was almost invariably accompanied by a cup of coffee or surreptitious scotch, cigarette and cigar smoke in the air, and some loud and choice cussing. Writing a breaking story was pedal-to-the-metal work -- a furious dash to any breaking-news finish.
The story never was perfect and yet reporters often strove for perfection -- a complete and balanced and coherent story -- over and over again. Some were better than others. Whatever the success, it always implied failure: Human stories are never complete and words cannot ever truly convey them.
But within those parameters, diversion was crucial to the quality and coherence of the story ... a rest period in which the mental muscles relaxed. Three minutes to deadline? Take at least one for a cup of really bad office coffee.
Rest and relaxation may be anathema to work/money-addicted employers intent on squeezing every last drop of 'productivity' out of employees, but where they cannot factor in the literal financial benefits of relaxation, I think they are falling down on their job.
Now, it seems, Japan, a nation full of workaholics, is considering making a law that would compel employers to make sure their workers take vacation days and otherwise unwind.
"Productivity" ... and the law of diminishing returns. On the one hand everyone would like to sell more widgets and is therefore keen to have workers work harder. On the other hand, if the work load gets to big -- as for example by not clearly defining the responsibilities of individual workers -- then corners will need to be cut and mediocrity will gain a foothold. Customers will only put up with so much mediocrity before they go elsewhere. And once they're gone, it is hard to win them back ... i.e. 'maximize profits.'Legislation that will be submitted during the parliamentary session that began Jan. 26 aims to ensure workers get the rest they need. In a break with past practice, it will become the legal responsibility of employers to ensure workers take their holidays....Part of the problem has been that many people fear resentment from co-workers if they take days off, a real concern in a conformist culture that values harmony....About 22 percent of Japanese work more than 49 hours a week, compared with 16 percent of Americans, 11 percent of the French and Germans, according to data compiled by the Japanese government. South Koreans seem even more workaholic, at 35 percent.
In Zen Buddhism, there is a saying: "A day without work is a day without eating." At a mundane level, this is a stab at the heart of social conscience, a quid pro quo of individual and social existence. Eating, obviously, is crucial to life. But without examining what it is that constitutes "work," how could anyone be other than a candidate for the ulcer farm putting out a mediocre product? How could anyone adequately know what work is if s/he didn't likewise know what relaxation was? Isn't this a package deal -- the one tending on the other? Could the richness of spiritual life be much more than a mediocre bluff if there were no ability to live comfortably in a world that ignored what passes for spiritual endeavor?
Sure, there are listless, lazy fuck-offs in any endeavor, but I'm not sure which is more debilitating to success -- the laziness that seeks to skirt the effort required for honest reward or the lock-step fire and brimstone of 'productivity.'
Thursday, February 5, 2015
lying: ain't it the truth?
Lying is an activity usually reserved either to keep something hidden or to attain a goal the liar is unwilling to straightforward about.
Religions and other well-coiffed social efforts tend to disdain and discourage lying, but when push comes to shove, I wonder if the truth, whatever it may be, could be revealed even in the best of circumstances. Anyone can lie, but can anyone actually tell the truth? I don't know.
Is truth as touted merely a matter of public accolade? If my ethics are bounded by a cheering public sentiment, does that make me moral? Is it lying or not to use words like "misspoke" when referring to lies? Is sincerity an excuse worth heeding? And if, by chance, a liar were to reverse course and lay his cards on the table, would that then imply he was telling the truth?
Don't get me wrong -- I do not intend to promote some slick, self-serving cynicism that doubts and tears down at every turn. I am not a Republican. But I am interested both in the willingness to tell lies (as I have) and the inability to stop doing so. Relativism is a cheap date.
As a delicately genteel nudge from the past once had it:
Naturally, I can bring a hundred excuses to bear when it comes to lying: Everybody's doing it, so it must be OK; it's for the greater good; I forgot; it's a kindness; the dog ate my homework; I am sincere; I want to be a good person; I screwed the pooch even if I cannot know who or what the pooch is ... etc. etc. etc.
I guess Mark Twain had it about right when he said, "There are lies, damned lies and statistics." It's such a rich and nourishing field that I can hardly imagine anyone's putting the plough back in the barn.
Religions and other well-coiffed social efforts tend to disdain and discourage lying, but when push comes to shove, I wonder if the truth, whatever it may be, could be revealed even in the best of circumstances. Anyone can lie, but can anyone actually tell the truth? I don't know.
Williams may be squirming after entering the news spotlight he is accustomed to shining on others, but his 'betrayal' of public trust hardly strikes me as unusual or even especially reprehensible in the world of agitation-and-propaganda he inhabits. He, like any CEO or individual, might wish to be believed and accredited, but which is more sensible? -- believing or disbelieving? Am I wrong or is trustworthiness/ethics these days based more on a majority sentiment and less on any verifiable fact?One of America's most famous news anchors has apologised after a story he repeatedly told about coming under fire in Iraq was revealed to be untrue.NBC's Brian Williams said he was on a helicopter forced down in 2003, but veterans have now disputed his account.
Is truth as touted merely a matter of public accolade? If my ethics are bounded by a cheering public sentiment, does that make me moral? Is it lying or not to use words like "misspoke" when referring to lies? Is sincerity an excuse worth heeding? And if, by chance, a liar were to reverse course and lay his cards on the table, would that then imply he was telling the truth?
Don't get me wrong -- I do not intend to promote some slick, self-serving cynicism that doubts and tears down at every turn. I am not a Republican. But I am interested both in the willingness to tell lies (as I have) and the inability to stop doing so. Relativism is a cheap date.
As a delicately genteel nudge from the past once had it:
I love myselfI say so unabashedly: I prefer the truth. I do not like liars. I say these things without much investigation: Let's face it -- it sounds good and I like the warm nods and accolades that saying so may elicit. I freely admit that lies are some of the best implements when it comes to winkling out the truth. But into that stew, if it's to be worth a shit, I feel compelled at add the spiciness of, "OK try to tell the truth without lying. Go ahead! I D-double-dare you!"
I think I'm grand.
I go to the movies
And hold my hand.
I put my arm
Around my waist.
And when I'm fresh,
I slap my face.
Naturally, I can bring a hundred excuses to bear when it comes to lying: Everybody's doing it, so it must be OK; it's for the greater good; I forgot; it's a kindness; the dog ate my homework; I am sincere; I want to be a good person; I screwed the pooch even if I cannot know who or what the pooch is ... etc. etc. etc.
I guess Mark Twain had it about right when he said, "There are lies, damned lies and statistics." It's such a rich and nourishing field that I can hardly imagine anyone's putting the plough back in the barn.
Wednesday, February 4, 2015
Taiwan plane crash
A plane carrying mostly Chinese tourists has crashed into ariver in Taiwan, killing at least 19 people.Dramatic video footage emerged showing the TransAsia Airways plane clipping a bridge as it came down shortly after take-off from a Taipei airport.The plane, carrying 58 people, has broken up and the fuselage is lying half-submerged in the Keelung River. Rescue efforts are ongoing.
Tuesday, February 3, 2015
scientific "dunno"
Like scientific mysteries? Then check out the Oxford Electric Bell, a battery-powered device that's still ringing 175 years after it was made, the Smithsonian reports. Sitting in the Clarendon Laboratory at Oxford University, it makes a little metal ball move swiftly back and forth between two bells.
the authority game
This morning, in email, I was greeted by Albert Einstein and his observation,
How I have disliked authority and its often-twisted and manipulative wiles. No doubt others have too ... battling the uphill battle that culminates, sometimes with terrifying simplicity, in the fact that you are the boss and as such are responsible. After what may be a lifetime of carping, suddenly the dime drops and, yes, there is no other authority.
It really does take some getting used to, but facts, in the end, are easier than fictions.
To punish me for my contempt for authority, fate made me an authority myself.The observation was appended to a blog post and served as a jumping-off point for rumination... a good hook that lodged itself with me as well.
How I have disliked authority and its often-twisted and manipulative wiles. No doubt others have too ... battling the uphill battle that culminates, sometimes with terrifying simplicity, in the fact that you are the boss and as such are responsible. After what may be a lifetime of carping, suddenly the dime drops and, yes, there is no other authority.
It really does take some getting used to, but facts, in the end, are easier than fictions.
Republican inability
Watching the TV news last night, there were the interviews that targeted the national budget proposal President Barack Obama has sent to the Congress for consideration. It's unthinkably enormous.
But once again -- as it seems too frequently in the past -- I waited in vain for a substantive Republican rebuttal to the Democrat initiative.
The Republican talking heads, as before, were willing to attack Obama's vision, but at no point did I hear even one of them saying, "I don't like Obama's approach. Here is a better one."
How can you believe someone whose point of view takes no risks, not to mention ignores the nation it has sworn to represent and nourish? The approach is so obviously self-serving and callow and shameless ... however popular. OK, you're kool at tearing down; now ... what can you substantively build?
But once again -- as it seems too frequently in the past -- I waited in vain for a substantive Republican rebuttal to the Democrat initiative.
The Republican talking heads, as before, were willing to attack Obama's vision, but at no point did I hear even one of them saying, "I don't like Obama's approach. Here is a better one."
How can you believe someone whose point of view takes no risks, not to mention ignores the nation it has sworn to represent and nourish? The approach is so obviously self-serving and callow and shameless ... however popular. OK, you're kool at tearing down; now ... what can you substantively build?
three-person babies
MPs [members of parliament] will hold a crucial vote later [today] to decide whether to allow the creation of babies using DNA from three people.They will have a free vote on the technique, which is aimed at preventing deadly genetic diseases being passed from mother to child.The UK could become the first country to legalise three-person babies and it could help about 150 couples a year.It has sparked fierce ethical debate and senior Church figures have called for the procedure to be blocked.
outhouse wisdom/deep meaning?
Woke and rose at 3:30, before I had had a chance to consult the clock. By the time I did see it, I was already into a getting-dressed-getting-coffee mode and some ironic voice took refuge in Ben Franklin's 18th century, "early to bed and early to rise makes a man healthy, wealthy and wise."
Bill McKechnie, an longtime friend now dead, once revised this Poor Richard's Almanack touchstone to read, "early to bed and early to rise and you never see any of your friends." McKechnie's wit lay not just in the wry laziness that countered Franklin's Calvinistic hard work and uprightness, but also in the fucked-up rhythm. It made me smile at 3:30: How many of my friends were up and running at 3:30, an hour when the hard-working are often asleep? Well, at least McKechnie is getting his zzzzz's and I am anything but a hard-worker.
Almanacs in the 18th century were apparently as popular as they are today, being then as now a compendium that offered "a mixture of seasonal weather forecasts, practical household hints, puzzles, and other amusements," according to Wikipedia.
Outhouse pastimes, in short, but also a summing up of vast and desirable philosophies.
Hard work is generally the measure of anything worthwhile, but the notion that good results could be attained without a good sweat persists in the mind and deserves correction. A nutshell is often useful and easier than investigating the philosophy it represents.
It's interesting who picks up what nutshells around in a mental filing box. These silver-tongued bon mots are not exactly serious but neither are they entirely silly. They are not exactly important, but neither are they unimportant. For example, I grew up remembering Ben Franklin and also liking Beatles member John Lennon's "life is what happens while you are making other plans."
Like others, I imagine, sometimes I am willing to investigate the wit and wisdom that comes off my own lazy-bones tongue. But sometimes I just make an utterance as a dismissal -- a walking stick I can lean on in place of actual work: Here is something true, so there's no point in breaking a sweat. "Love they neighbor as thyself" is nifty enough so that, well, I can go back to bed and let others eat my virtuous dust.
I wonder what touchstones others are sewing or have sewn into their tapestries these days. It wouldn't surprise me to think that someone didn't know who the hell Ben Franklin was, let alone his almanac. Still the tendency to distill and rely on and sometimes investigate nutshells is hardly dead, I imagine.
So what are the touchstones of today? I grew up with mine; what are my children growing up with? What small nutshells litter their forest floor? Under what banners do they alternatively lounge and investigate, rely on and implement?
Maybe because it's early and I am vaguely surly, all I can think of is
Bill McKechnie, an longtime friend now dead, once revised this Poor Richard's Almanack touchstone to read, "early to bed and early to rise and you never see any of your friends." McKechnie's wit lay not just in the wry laziness that countered Franklin's Calvinistic hard work and uprightness, but also in the fucked-up rhythm. It made me smile at 3:30: How many of my friends were up and running at 3:30, an hour when the hard-working are often asleep? Well, at least McKechnie is getting his zzzzz's and I am anything but a hard-worker.
Almanacs in the 18th century were apparently as popular as they are today, being then as now a compendium that offered "a mixture of seasonal weather forecasts, practical household hints, puzzles, and other amusements," according to Wikipedia.
Outhouse pastimes, in short, but also a summing up of vast and desirable philosophies.
Hard work is generally the measure of anything worthwhile, but the notion that good results could be attained without a good sweat persists in the mind and deserves correction. A nutshell is often useful and easier than investigating the philosophy it represents.
It's interesting who picks up what nutshells around in a mental filing box. These silver-tongued bon mots are not exactly serious but neither are they entirely silly. They are not exactly important, but neither are they unimportant. For example, I grew up remembering Ben Franklin and also liking Beatles member John Lennon's "life is what happens while you are making other plans."
Like others, I imagine, sometimes I am willing to investigate the wit and wisdom that comes off my own lazy-bones tongue. But sometimes I just make an utterance as a dismissal -- a walking stick I can lean on in place of actual work: Here is something true, so there's no point in breaking a sweat. "Love they neighbor as thyself" is nifty enough so that, well, I can go back to bed and let others eat my virtuous dust.
So what are the touchstones of today? I grew up with mine; what are my children growing up with? What small nutshells litter their forest floor? Under what banners do they alternatively lounge and investigate, rely on and implement?
Maybe because it's early and I am vaguely surly, all I can think of is
It ain't what you've got; it's what you git.
Monday, February 2, 2015
"Kim"
![]() |
| Rudyard Kipling (1865-1936) |
But I was after the novel, "Kim," by Rudyard Kipling, a turn-of-the-20th-century Nobel prize winner, after pulling the book off the shelf for a re-read. I needed Wikipedia or some other condenser of information to tell me the tale that I find magnetically-difficult to discern as I read the story itself. Surely my mother had read me this story when I was little, and I know I read it myself at one time or another ... and how the hell had I managed that: The uses of language often seem little more than a viscous gibberish... one that audiences had gobbled and digested with gusto when the book first appeared as a series of magazine articles in 1901. No shit -- it's like reading a foreign language masquerading as English.
"Kim" is the story of a teenaged white youth, burned brown by the sun, who wanders the streets of Lahore with his equally-impoverished friends. He becomes the disciple of a Tibetan lama and, more interestingly, becomes a spy in the tangential employ of the British who ruled India at the time.
But the style of writing at the time was not what it is today and that, for some reason, keeps me turning the pages. What mind -- let alone, what popular mind -- allowed magazine readers to gobble this up, to be thrilled and intrigued and most of all understanding what the hell the author was talking about?
In the entrance-hall stood the larger figures of the Greco-Buddhist sculptures done, savants know how long since, by forgotten workmen whose hands were feeling, and not unskilfully, for the mysteriously transmitted Grecian touch.Nor is the quote above the most ornate-to-impenetrable in my mind. One thing's for sure -- it ain't Facebook with its reliably unreliable premises couched in up-to-date jargon. But in what way did magazine readers of that day leap into this tale of a pint-sized spy in the mysterious East? Kipling's writing won a Nobel prize, so presumably he was speaking the lingua franca of English.
There is something enticing about wading through this book. It's as if, on top of the story itself, there is some keyhole into the minds of those who might be my forebears. The impatience I might otherwise feel when someone can't seem to "get to the point" is on hold for the moment. But I am inclined to say that the book is not for the faint of heart, however rousing the story.
super moments in the Super Bowl
With almost no time remaining in the Super Bowl yesterday, first there was a spectacular reception by the Seattle Seahawks and then, unbelievably, there was a game-winning interception by the New England Patriots. The final score was 28-24.
It's nice to watch a much-touted game and have it turn out to be a pretty good game. Too often what is advertised as the "best" or the "biggest" or the "first-est with the most-est" turns out to be eyewash and hype that cannot compare with less-touted efforts ... it's frequent enough to make anyone steer clear of the alleged winners.
When I was a reporter, it didn't take long to figure out that if you wanted to know what the governor was doing, you never tried to talk to the governor ... always talk to someone further from the spotlight who was actually doing the work. Or, in the military, don't ask the general, ask the sergeant. Or in religion, don't consult the pope.
It was a good Super Bowl despite the feeding-frenzy hype.
It's nice to watch a much-touted game and have it turn out to be a pretty good game. Too often what is advertised as the "best" or the "biggest" or the "first-est with the most-est" turns out to be eyewash and hype that cannot compare with less-touted efforts ... it's frequent enough to make anyone steer clear of the alleged winners.
When I was a reporter, it didn't take long to figure out that if you wanted to know what the governor was doing, you never tried to talk to the governor ... always talk to someone further from the spotlight who was actually doing the work. Or, in the military, don't ask the general, ask the sergeant. Or in religion, don't consult the pope.
It was a good Super Bowl despite the feeding-frenzy hype.
making stuff up
Diaphanous....
As fiercely feminine as a long-tailed cat, inching nearer, belly to the earth....
Smooth and assured as the cue ball rolling across green felt....
Scudding off the rooftops like some fractured whipped cream....
I watch this morning's snowstorm and rush to light the narrative fuses, one by one, as if the storm were not enough, as if there were dots to connect and I were the just the self-involved magician to connect them.
I chalk it up to story-telling karma, another sounds-good bit of explanation, as if explanation could explain a snowstorm or a life. I do love stories and hence am more or less content to tell the lies that come to hand.
It's just a snowstorm of course, but still I need fix it, to plump it up like some pillow that could be made 'more' comfortable. True, stories interest me more than TV, but sometimes it strikes me as a strange imperative ... so second-hand and yet not second-hand at all.
"Everything touches everything else" ... don't be fatuous! Wisdom is for nitwits.
I am a nitwit. Making stuff up is what I do. Is that really such a big deal?
The Hindus have the tale of a tinker who comes to town with a vat slung over his shoulder. He sets the vat in the middle of the town square and invites villagers to bring their new-woven cloth and he will dye it for them. The villagers line up.
The first villager says he would like his cloth "blue." The tinker lowers the cloth into the vat and out it comes, "blue." The next woman longs for "red." Into the the same vat the produced "blue" goes her bolt ... and out it comes, "red." And so it goes, down the line of villagers -- each expressing a preference and each having the preference met out of the same vat.
Finally, there is only one man left. He steps forward and says to the tinker, "I would like my cloth to be the color of what is in the vat."
I always loved the Hindu tableau. It seemed to have lived long enough to know that a furrowed brow and fierce determination could not really hold a candle to the stories that came with a smile of recognition, a bit of laughter, and an unfreighted message. Accessible. Hinduism seemed old enough to ply its trade without the laurels. It seemed to have lived long enough to be a grown-up: Just because there is no story is no reason not to tell a story.
Or anyway, that's the color of my cloth.
As fiercely feminine as a long-tailed cat, inching nearer, belly to the earth....
Smooth and assured as the cue ball rolling across green felt....
Scudding off the rooftops like some fractured whipped cream....
I watch this morning's snowstorm and rush to light the narrative fuses, one by one, as if the storm were not enough, as if there were dots to connect and I were the just the self-involved magician to connect them.
I chalk it up to story-telling karma, another sounds-good bit of explanation, as if explanation could explain a snowstorm or a life. I do love stories and hence am more or less content to tell the lies that come to hand.
It's just a snowstorm of course, but still I need fix it, to plump it up like some pillow that could be made 'more' comfortable. True, stories interest me more than TV, but sometimes it strikes me as a strange imperative ... so second-hand and yet not second-hand at all.
"Everything touches everything else" ... don't be fatuous! Wisdom is for nitwits.
I am a nitwit. Making stuff up is what I do. Is that really such a big deal?
The Hindus have the tale of a tinker who comes to town with a vat slung over his shoulder. He sets the vat in the middle of the town square and invites villagers to bring their new-woven cloth and he will dye it for them. The villagers line up.
The first villager says he would like his cloth "blue." The tinker lowers the cloth into the vat and out it comes, "blue." The next woman longs for "red." Into the the same vat the produced "blue" goes her bolt ... and out it comes, "red." And so it goes, down the line of villagers -- each expressing a preference and each having the preference met out of the same vat.
Finally, there is only one man left. He steps forward and says to the tinker, "I would like my cloth to be the color of what is in the vat."
I always loved the Hindu tableau. It seemed to have lived long enough to know that a furrowed brow and fierce determination could not really hold a candle to the stories that came with a smile of recognition, a bit of laughter, and an unfreighted message. Accessible. Hinduism seemed old enough to ply its trade without the laurels. It seemed to have lived long enough to be a grown-up: Just because there is no story is no reason not to tell a story.
Or anyway, that's the color of my cloth.
Sunday, February 1, 2015
politically-correct sharia
In basic training, the army private who took my particulars in order to create my dog tags was horrified to note that I had written "N/A" (not applicable) in the space reserved for "religious preference." We were in the South and the private, judging by his accent, was a product of that South in all its sometimes-ferocious religiosity.
"C'mon man!" he said to me in utter disbelief and with a sincerely-wounded look on his face, "you gotta be something." And because the pain on his face seemed unfeigned, I replied, "OK. Put down 'Unitarian.'"
The pain on his face was replaced by suspicion. "What's that?" he asked in a tone suggesting I was not going to put one over on him and profess a sneaky devil worship. I thought a minute, looked again at his young and earnest face and figured there was no point in making his life any more difficult than it already was. "It's a kind of protestant," I said, fudging things a bit, but wiping the pained suspicion from his face.
"OK," he said. "How do you spell it?"
And so it was that the two tags that hung around my neck as they did for every soldier read "UNITARIAN." At the time, it was as far removed from religion as I could think of while still toeing the religious mark.
And because basic training was full of training exercises and mental conditioning, my religious preference damn near got me out of going to the mandatory religious meeting that was part of basic training -- one for Catholics, one for Jews and one for Protestants. When my squad leader asked me why I hadn't lined up for one of the segments, I told him I was a "Unitarian," hoping he wouldn't know what it was and would be too embarrassed to ask and so I might avoid another droning meeting where little or nothing would be learned. My squad leader was not quite that stupid. Close, but no cigar. "What's that?" he asked. And I was forced to say something, after which he sent me off with the Protestants to listen to a spiritual pep talk.
And I survived.
More than that, although I didn't know it at the time, I learned something about the culture in which I lived. I wasn't a raucous atheist or anything. I just didn't care much for religion and wasn't above the occasional snarky riff. But I was educated: Learning about what didn't/doesn't interest me is worth learning. Religion in the military is a terrific bit of contradiction and hypocrisy, but it's human and understandable and, more important, it's enormously popular. Anyone with two brain cells to rub together knows that when in the midst of a popular belief, it is wise to investigate before contradicting.
I survived the military's nod to spirituality as I had survived morning and mealtime prayers in a high school founded by a religious organization. Likewise I survived Bible class and am grateful I was forced to take it. No one pissed and moaned about "church and state" -- Bible class was just part of the curriculum. Those who believed something else were not excluded ... in a culture that is Christian-based in its majority, they were simply being educated to their surroundings. Education is more important than belief ... even very politically-correct belief.
This morning, a friend sent along a blog critique entitled, "Not a very PC thing to say: How the language police are
perverting liberalism". The target of the essay is a Mississippi school district that has refused to honor court rulings on the inclusion of "God" et al in its curriculum. The court said don't do it; the school district said up-yours. Atheists, humanists and those with minority sexual preferences take umbrage at their exclusion within what might be thought of as a kind of Christian sharia. Its cruelty can be a no-kidding-around matter.
But it also occurs to me that if everyone is acknowledged and everyone is 'included,' the real-time impact of a particular point of view is often reduced to pablum. If human beings could actually be corralled and defined within an ethical barbed wire, how true would that be? It might be kinder and less cruel, but how true?
Isn't a part of America's current disenchantment with politics the recognition that bamboozling the electorate with no clearly-stated position is hardly the truth? Being all things to all (wo)men really won't wash... in politics, religion or personal relationships. And if that is true, then perhaps it would be better to investigate the leaning that actually exists and ....
Survive on a more realistic, better informed and less politically-correct footing. Until there is some honest understanding of why your personal-favorite idiots might think what they do, won't we all remain idiots?
Oh well ... I'm not entirely sure what this ramble is in aid of.
Saturday, January 31, 2015
cutting off the snake's head
What is it that U.S. and other power bases do not understand?
Around the world, one "dictator" or another, one "insurgent" leader or another, one "bad man" or another is cloaked by the U.S. et all in the glory of being the villain du jour.
Then he is assassinated or dies and the U.S. or other governmental entities crow, "Cut off the head and the snake will die."
And once the snake's purported head is in fact cut off ... the mission, the cause and the blood-letting persists.
Does this not suggest that another approach might be more effective? If you don't ask what it is that someone wants/needs and why they want it and then attempt to address those wants/needs, is killing them the answer to the question? It all feels like the exasperated parent who snaps at a reluctant child, "Shut up and eat your spinach!" Yes, there are "terrorists" with violence-laced, disproportionate and pig-headed demands -- who are dying to die -- but is it true that none of their goals/demands is within the realm of human sanity? I find that hard to believe.
A U.S.-backed action in the Philippines -- how wonderful it's not the Middle East for once, right? -- brought all this to mind.
Marwan seems to deserve a round of U.S. applause: It was he, among others, who allowed America to march resolutely towards a goal of allowing war to distract from more complex issues at home ... that and, as an adjunct, keeping the electorate in thrall to the fear of snakes.
I burn your books, you burn mine
There are those who adore books as if they were talismans of greatness and virtue and such people are horrified that a book burning took place. For them, book burnings are an apostasy.BAGHDAD (AP) — When Islamic State group militants invaded the Central Library of Mosul earlier this month, they were on a mission to destroy a familiar enemy: other people's ideas.Residents say the extremists smashed the locks that had protected the biggest repository of learning in the northern Iraq town, and loaded around 2,000 books — including children's stories, poetry, philosophy and tomes on sports, health, culture and science — into six pickup trucks. They left only Islamic texts.
But worse than that, in my mind, is the concrete fragility of the world view that indulges its feeding-frenzy fires: Are someone else's ideas so threatening to my philosophy and if so, what does that say about my philosophy? How convincing and practical, to say nothing of kind, are ideas that excoriate a world that does not share them?
This might all be hypothetical hand-wringing, if the feeding frenzy wrought by group-think agreement (good, bad and indifferent) did not end up spilling others' blood.
The mad dogs of group-think -- a spinoff of what may be elevated and inspiring and genuinely nourishing starting points -- are ... well they scare the shit out of me.
And what is socially true is a capacity that is singular and personal as well. I burn your books and you burn mine from time to time.
Lord, do not save me from the utter thoughtlessness of others. Instead, save me from the mad-dog and subtlely shaped stupidity within!
Let's just agree to be infidels, OK?
meditation video game
And now, of course, I can't find it any more.
A video of a meditating bald man/monk sitting facing the computer-user while an animated fly buzzes around ... in one ear and out the other, on his face, etc. The moment the computer user attempts to do anything with the cursor -- swat or catch the fly, for example -- the man's eyes pop open in disgusted surprise that anyone would interrupt meditation over so minor a matter. "Don't zzzzzz" the screen advises. The effect is both funny and serious.
I can't find it and save it as I should have. Maybe the video no longer exists. Or maybe I have just been zzzz-ing too much.
I mention it in case anyone else was savvy enough to save it and is willing to put a link here.
A video of a meditating bald man/monk sitting facing the computer-user while an animated fly buzzes around ... in one ear and out the other, on his face, etc. The moment the computer user attempts to do anything with the cursor -- swat or catch the fly, for example -- the man's eyes pop open in disgusted surprise that anyone would interrupt meditation over so minor a matter. "Don't zzzzzz" the screen advises. The effect is both funny and serious.
I can't find it and save it as I should have. Maybe the video no longer exists. Or maybe I have just been zzzz-ing too much.
I mention it in case anyone else was savvy enough to save it and is willing to put a link here.
Thursday, January 29, 2015
intellectual coward
The Associated Press was in contact this morning, seeking confirmation of my mother's death and other odds and ends. The requests sent me here and there around the house and put me on a my-mother's-death frequency.
I wondered what I had learned from her. Probably a lot, much of it so tightly woven within as to be forgotten. But it crossed my mind that one of the positive things she taught me, though she never said it directly, was, "don't be an intellectual coward." She never was and, as a result, she was lonely I think.
What is an intellectual coward? Taking a swing at it, I guess I'd say an intellectual coward was someone who claimed to know something and was graceless enough not to admit that s/he was too tired or busy to do the homework implicit in that knowledge. Going the distance is too damned exhausting and it's easier, within or without, to say, "I know."
But I see nothing wrong with admitting that sure-fire or even much-touted knowledge is just the point beyond which the one with the knowledge refused to go. There are gross versions of this -- think "terrorist" or "hero" or "love" -- and there are far subtler versions -- writers or sports bettors or philosophers or whoever who rely on the sweat of others and then claim it for their own ... without that graceful nod to the distance they refused to go ... and for which they expect applause.
It takes some balls not to be an intellectual coward and my mother had balls.
cold weather
It is cold this morning -- minus two degrees Fahrenheit at the moment. The dawn sky was dotted earlier with pink clouds as if to bring credibility to the old saw, "Red sky in the morning/ Sailors take warning./ Red sky at night/ Sailors delight." The forecast promises a few inches of snow later today.
Cold ... a hard cold.
Bundle up as I have. Wrap yourself in layers of clothing...
I once listened to an East German telephone operator chatting with a fellow telephone operator in another city. It was so cold, she said, that her son had put on 17 sweaters. I listened to the telephone tap tape several times to make sure I had it right ... 17 sweaters.
Swaddle yourself in another and another bit of clothing.
Ordinary clothing, monastic clothing, police officer clothing, businessman clothing, homeless-person clothing, military clothing, au courant clothing, behind the times clothing ... layer after layer ...
The cold doesn't mind, but I do.
Cold ... a hard cold.
Bundle up as I have. Wrap yourself in layers of clothing...
I once listened to an East German telephone operator chatting with a fellow telephone operator in another city. It was so cold, she said, that her son had put on 17 sweaters. I listened to the telephone tap tape several times to make sure I had it right ... 17 sweaters.
Swaddle yourself in another and another bit of clothing.
Ordinary clothing, monastic clothing, police officer clothing, businessman clothing, homeless-person clothing, military clothing, au courant clothing, behind the times clothing ... layer after layer ...
The cold doesn't mind, but I do.
the price of Buddhist ritual
For the Buddhism-beckoned in the audience, here is an article from the BBC entitled "China's super-rich communist Buddhists."
"They may not be able to buy their way into Nirvana," Geshe Sonam says, "but in Buddhism, you can get more karmic reward the more money you spend on rituals."Sometimes, but not often, I wonder how far anyone can stretch a perfectly-good rubber band before it snaps.
Wednesday, January 28, 2015
"Let's Go Fly a Kite"
Because I ran across the 2013 movie, "Saving Mr. Banks," a film about the tart and emotionally-immured author P.L. Travers and Walt Disney's attempt to make a movie of her "Mary Poppins," I have now got the following song stuck in my mind. It probably won't have the impact it does in the context of the movie, but still....
Israelis jail stone-thrower, 14
BETIN, West Bank (AP) — The fate of a 14-year-old Palestinian girl, tried before an Israeli military court for hurling rocks at passing cars in the West Bank and sentenced to two months in prison, has gripped Palestinians who say her treatment demonstrates Israel's excessive measures against stone-throwing youth....The Israeli military said al-Khatib was charged with stone-throwing, attempted stone-throwing and possession of a knife and that under a plea bargain, she was sentenced to two months in prison and a $1,500 fine.
loss of what?
A strange sadness overcame me yesterday when I happened to learn of the death of my first bed-time girlfriend. The sadness seemed to complement or flesh out what I didn't seem to feel about the death of my mother on Jan. 11.
In fifty-odd intervening years, I hadn't kept up with the life and times of the girl who had popped my cherry and led me towards a richer and more confused and more human roundness. I found her married name almost by accident via the Great God Google. She died last year at 70 of cancer. She had had two daughters. Her husband survived her.
The obituary gave the information and something inside me exclaimed, "No! Things aren't supposed to be like that!"
Like what? Like ... however tenuous and uninformed my memories were, still they were my memories and formed a bit of who I liked to think I was. My memories were serious even when I didn't pay them much mind. Because the memories were alive, the person was alive ... and somehow was not allowed to die until the memories died. But of course things don't work like that.
In some small but pervasive way, I felt bereft and sad and surprised and upset.
My mother died at 98. It was her time, I guess, and, however complex the weaving she made in my mind, still I did not feel deprived or deeply sad. Maybe that will come later. Maybe not. But there was something touching and tearing about the 'loss' of a young woman with whom I laughed and gained a little humanity.
I'm not sure exactly what was lost, but I felt a sadness I imagine others feel when someone close dies ... even when they are not close.
In fifty-odd intervening years, I hadn't kept up with the life and times of the girl who had popped my cherry and led me towards a richer and more confused and more human roundness. I found her married name almost by accident via the Great God Google. She died last year at 70 of cancer. She had had two daughters. Her husband survived her.
The obituary gave the information and something inside me exclaimed, "No! Things aren't supposed to be like that!"
Like what? Like ... however tenuous and uninformed my memories were, still they were my memories and formed a bit of who I liked to think I was. My memories were serious even when I didn't pay them much mind. Because the memories were alive, the person was alive ... and somehow was not allowed to die until the memories died. But of course things don't work like that.
In some small but pervasive way, I felt bereft and sad and surprised and upset.
My mother died at 98. It was her time, I guess, and, however complex the weaving she made in my mind, still I did not feel deprived or deeply sad. Maybe that will come later. Maybe not. But there was something touching and tearing about the 'loss' of a young woman with whom I laughed and gained a little humanity.
I'm not sure exactly what was lost, but I felt a sadness I imagine others feel when someone close dies ... even when they are not close.
flawlessness
A friend sent along the statements relating to the six-month withdrawal of a Zen teacher from his post as honcho for the Mountains and Rivers Order because he had "betrayed" his vows by camouflaging his relationship with a woman other than his long-time partner.
Although I have implicitly and explicitly beaten the drum, both within and without, for something akin to a "flawless life" when it came to spiritual efforts, the link my friend sent along left me tired out.
Flawlessness strikes me these days as a flawed notion, however hopeful and bright it may seem on the face of it. It may be inspiring as all get-out and may push a student in whatever field to excellence and a deeper understanding, but, well....
Things are indeed flawless.
Saying so is deeply flawed, a mote in the eye of the beholder ... and a misuse of energy that might be employed better in other ways ... lacing up unlaced shoes, for example.
The Buddha wasn't a Buddhist, and, nor, should sincere students get sidetracked or bamboozled.
I can hear the 'discussion' sabers being rattled in a variety of sheaths.
Sabers need to be carried.
Carrying stuff is not my best thing these days.
Tuesday, January 27, 2015
"everyone has suffered a tragedy"
![]() |
| Anne Morrow Lindbergh, 1918 |
In 1932, the kidnapping of Charles A. Lindbergh, Jr., aged 20 months, was, in H. L. Mencken's words, "the biggest story since the Resurrection." The boy was kidnapped, then found murdered and the perpetrator, who proclaimed his innocence to the end, was electrocuted.
The high profile that both parents had in the public eye (Anne was likewise an aviator and also an author and journalist) sent news stories through the roof. Yet here she was, so many years later (1980's?), sitting in my TV talking about I-don't-remember-what-precisely.
And finally, the shoe dropped and the interviewer asked what had to be asked ... what had it been like to have a child kidnapped? Anne Morrow Lindbergh did not flinch, even if I did. I had watched the interview up to that point with a certain skepticism about this well-heeled and well-connected personality -- "another smoothie," some class-conscious voice suggested in my mind ... everything under control, plenty of money, and no way into whatever inner sanctum she protected.
Anne Morrow Lindbergh did not flinch, but she sat still and straight and silent for a noticeable moment. But when she opened her mouth, she blew my socks off. She did, in one sense, deflect the question, CEO-fashion, but in another sense she hit the nail hard and right on the head. What she said was:
I think everybody has suffered a tragedy.I didn't care if she was obfuscating or lying or waxing wise in the place of honesty. What she said, it struck me in that moment, was the truth or close enough for folk-singing. And what an excellent premise her words encased. And what an excellent conundrum they proposed. On the one hand, the presumption suggested we should all be a little more gentle with each other. And together with that there was the question, "how does anyone ingest, digest or 'solve' the tragedy that attends on this life like a shadow in the sunlight?" No one else cares, but I care about my cares. No one else cares, but you care about your cares. The universe is poker-faced and the tragic fires burn bright.
Today marks the 70th anniversary of the World War II liberation of Auschwitz, one of a number of Nazi concentration camps in which millions of Jews, gypsies, and other 'untermenschen' were annihilated. It was an unspeakable tragedy which Jews and others try to recall and instill and remember. A tragedy beyond tragedy, much like other tragedies. Ironically, but still tragically, Israel visits some of the same thinking that went into Auschwitz on the latter-day Palestinians they do their best to eradicate under a righteous banner. Vile and horrific. A tragedy.
At Veterans Administration hospitals here in the U.S., many of the patients are still strangled by the tragedies they witnessed or took part in. Other veterans are not hospitalized and yet relive their tragedies every ... fucking ... day. Vile and horrific and hardly limited to U.S. service personnel. A tragedy.
There are wide-swath tragedies like the above and small-swath tragedies that afflict damn near anyone. It is hard not to wonder if a human being is a human being without a tragedy that lingers and claws, sometimes without noticing. Wide-swath tragedians may write off an individual's gremlins as "small potatoes by comparison," but comparing tragedies is self-centered and more unkind than it needs to be.
Bit by bit and drip by drop, the events dwindle in the rearview mirror of time and yet linger and lash, even as the universe remains impassive. There's no forgetting and no real ability to remember truly, but the tragedy can be as compelling as a rattlesnake biting a careless wrist.
Can anyone solve a tragedy by acceding to it through faulty memory? Tragedy is inescapable, little or large. The tragedies of others can hardly compare to This Tragedy ... but, but ... somehow to acknowledge tragedy -- up-close and personal -- and to learn that "this too shall pass" even if it never, ever passes is useful, if tragically hard.
I guess the best anyone can do is to pay attention and be patient and weep as necessary. The past cannot be undone any more than "learning from the past" stands much of a chance.
But there is the possibility -- touted by Buddhism but hardly limited to its limited realms -- of entering the world of tragedy with all the fear and loathing that implies and ameliorating the devil. You're right. It's no fucking joke, whatever the small smile on the face of the universe. But bit by bit and drop by drop, without insisting on maintaining what slips away ... the moments can become easier. Yes, yes and again yes ... it's tragic.
But in the meantime, remember that "everyone has suffered a tragedy."
Kindness is worth the price.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)















