Saturday, June 30, 2012

What Did the Vatican Know; When Did They Know It?


The road to the heaven we long for leads through the hell we have created. However apt that observation may be, still, it does not detract from the grueling nature of the pilgrimage.

These days, the priest sex abuse scandal in the United States and elsewhere appears to be gaining momentum as variety of unchurched legal systems pry loose documentation once reserved for locked drawers. Bit by horrific bit, the lawsuits pile up, the dioceses declare bankruptcy, priest applications dwindle, jury and grand jury testimony reaches the Internet, and the convictions for child molestation and/or associated cover-ups by the minions of the Vatican come to light. Gerald T. Slevin has given one pretty good smorgasbord round-up here.William Lindsey's "Bilgrimage" blog collects bits and pieces, snacks and main courses, as they occur. And there are myriad other sites and sources.

But the other day I received a laundry list of Roman Catholic Church documents that goes some way towards answering the question, "what did the Vatican know and when did they know it." The compendium was offered in the decade-old book, "Sex, Priests, and Secret Codes: The Catholic Church's 2,000 Year Paper Trail of Sexual Abuse." Patrick J. Wall, one of the three authors of the book, sent the compendium and while I do not generally like relying on someone else's presentations, still these documents from within the church itself were so compelling, so first-hand, so sui generis ... well, I was ten years too late to the party, but the music was brand new in my ear.

These documents were not some sappy, hand-wringing blog. They are actual-factual documents -- some complete with the Latin that Wall and his co-authors translated. What they depict is not just what the Vatican knew about sexual abuse and when they knew it, but also the ethos within which these poisonous weeds were nourished. I would love to write something distanced and measured and sane about all this, but I cannot ... and I apologize.

A host of disconnected metaphors chatters in my mind: To read these documents is to become like a steer in the Chicago stock yards -- stunned at first ... dizzy, disoriented, defenseless ... unaware and strangely uncaring that its throat will soon be slit. The language is so sincere, so enveloping and so ornate that you forget the first rule of honest argumentation: Stand up, speak up and shut up. To read these documents is to enter a Chinese opium den where customers were once described as "biting the clouds." Lulling as a mother's croon. You try to yank yourself back from the sweetness of the melody: "Why doesn't someone announce that the emperor is wearing no clothes?!" But the fact is that the emperor's clothes are so lovely that to challenge the loveliness would be to leave yourself, somehow, unloved and bereft. It is all as beguiling as it is diabolical and cruel.

As a matter of disclosure, I have never been a Roman Catholic. To the extent anyone wants to shoot ecclesiastical barbs, I guess I qualify conversationally as a "Zen Buddhist." I am not anti-Catholic. But my gorge rises at depredation and manipulation of the sort practiced in Rome and evidenced in these documents. The abuse of children is beyond the pale. I do not give a shit about the venue -- religious or otherwise. It is true that it has been a long time since I have wasted much time on any belief system, so perhaps my absence from that compulsive need-to-be-convinced realm has raised my vitriol level. I don't know. I do know I cannot apologize.

No one needs to read what is written here. I just felt compelled to compile it.

Below, listed in chronological order, are excerpts I have chosen at random from the entire compilation. I cannot pretend that they are inclusive or even necessarily the best or most compelling of excerpts. Some relate to abuse. Some relate to the backdrop against which the Vatican consolidated its being and ethos... its views of women, homosexuals, money and other aspects of a prescribed life. The excerpts are just what I can manage. I can find nothing in them that proclaims the "caritas" that is the foundation of Christianity. This is the kingdom of man and it is, like all hellish realms, brightly lit. Of all the documents referenced, perhaps the most astounding is that from 1962 -- an instruction on how church officials are to proceed in cases of solicitation or abuse: It is forty-four pages long, describes situations in which those who were not clerics would go to jail ... and yet makes not one mention of civil authority.

Through the centuries -- CENTURIES -- the church has roundly condemned using its confines as a means of  assuring or coercing sexual pleasure... heterosexual, homosexual and for all I know, dog- or sheep-sexual. But this pious condemnation and the punishments the church has proposed on paper stand in stark contrast to the collusive and arrogant maneuvers the church has deployed in the current abuse scandal. Read 'em and weep! Women, homosexuals, and those unconvinced by the authority and truth of the one true church -- duck and cover! It is all as if, when the church looks in the mirror and asks, "Mirror, mirror on the wall/ Who is the fairest of them all?" the answer is always reassuring. To put it bluntly, it is time to break that mirror.

The other day, I was suggesting to Jerry Slevin that he trim his admirable essays on the priest abuse scandal to more bite-sized morsels. Today, the shoe is on the other foot and the laugh is on me.

My thanks go out to Patrick Wall, a man with far greater tact, acuity, and patience than my own, and to my good friend, the Rev. Kobutsu Malone, who both assisted in the Internet creation of this post and remains the creator and sustainer of The Shimano Archive and Bergen Catholic High School Abuse

A complete list of the documents from which I have lifted excerpts is here; what follows are the excerpts:

309 AD or CE               THE CANONS OF ELVIRA

Can. 13. Virgins who have consecrated themselves to God, if they break their vow of
virginity and turn to lust instead, not realizing what they lose, shall not be given
communion at the end.
Can. 21. If anyone living in the city does not go to church for three Sundays, he shall be
kept out for a short time in order that his punishment be made public.
Can. 28. A bishop shall not take a gift from one who is not in communion.
Can. 33. Bishops, presbyters, and deacons and all other clerics having a position in the
ministry are ordered to abstain completely from their wives and not to have children.
Whoever, in fact, does this, shall be expelled from the dignity of the clerical state.
Can. 35. Women are forbidden to spend the night in a cemetery since often under the
pretext of prayer they secretly commit evil deeds.
Can. 47. If a baptized married man commits adultery, not once but often, he is to be
approached at the hour of death. If he promises to stop, communion shall be given him,
if he should recover and commit adultery again, he shall nevermore make a mockery of
the communion of peace.
Can. 67. It is forbidden for a woman. whether baptized or a catechumen, to have
anything to do with long-haired men or hairdressers; any who do this shall be kept from
communion.
Can. 71. Men who sexually abuse boys shall not be given communion even at the end.
Can. 81. Women shall not presume on their own, without their husbands signatures, to
write to lay women who are baptized, nor shall they accept anyone's letters of peace
addressed only to themselves.

44 comments:

  1. On a related note, the author of the article linked below makes a good point: do not confuse a "sex abuse scandal" with a "sex scandal".

    http://www.alternet.org/story/156105/stop_calling_it_a_sex_scandal/

    ReplyDelete
  2. I was not aware I had fallen into that trap ... couldn't find a "sex scandal" reference ... though the point is obviously well taken.

    ReplyDelete
  3. Genkaku---

    Didn't mean to suggest that you "fell into that trap". Sorry if my comment seemed to imply it.

    After reading the linked article, I couldn't help recalling the NYT piece entitled "Sex Scandal Has U.S. Buddhists Looking Within."

    ReplyDelete
  4. nice posting.. thanks for sharing.

    ReplyDelete
  5. Thanks for sharing a nice article.Wireless Security Consultants’job description can include a variety of different tasks.Companies need experienced professionals that can take care of every aspect of wireless network security.

    ReplyDelete
  6. Are you looking for the best and reliable statistics homework help services with best prices? GoAssignmentHelp.com team provides a global online platform for custom assignment writing. Our website is especially popular among students with do my assignment online and write my assignment for me requests who are ready to pay in order to get the online homework help they need. Our writing experts provide remarkable academic writing services in the domains such as Finance, accounting homework help, Business Law, Computer Science, Statistics, Management, Engineering, Essays, Dissertations, Marketing, Thesis, Coursework, etc. Our work shows the unique writing services that we provide. GoAssignmentHelp.com committed to providing 100% plagiarism free assignment writing answers within the deadline. Our pricing team always keeps in mind the budget of students, so we provide cheap and the best Assignment help at a very reasonable price. So Order your assignment now and rest we will do.

    ReplyDelete
  7. Thank you for sharing the useful post. A reader got a lot of information from this post and utilized it in their research. I also provide independent support for the outlook email. So if you are facing issues with the outlook account then contact me for outlook email support.
    Also Read: Outlook not connecting to server | Outlook send receive error

    ReplyDelete
  8. We are the best escort girls provider in Dwarka. Hire dwarka escort services at affordable rates, sexy model and housewife available 24/7. Call us now

    ReplyDelete
  9. The perfect way to get started with Microsoft 365 is gathering enough information and purchasing depending on your requirement. You can then easily download and install the software package by visiting microsoft365.com/setup , microsoft365.com/setup .

    ReplyDelete
  10. Get Microsoft 365 setup by visiting microsoft365.com/setup. Sign in to Microsoft account, enter the product key and get apps quickly. Download & use Microsoft365 setup wizard using microsoft365.com/setup site, follow instructions and install apps.Go to www.microsoft365/setup to get all the MS office 365 apps on your devices like Windows, Mac, and smartphones.

    ReplyDelete
  11. The Canon printer that can be downloaded via canon.com/ijsetup page is the best wireless printer that you can connect to your device and print data smoothly. Ij.start canon CD is not the well-suited technique to use ij.start.canon installation for longer. One can canon.com/ijsetup/mg2522 install from another origin if your device is having issues in the online installation or any other.Use ij.start cannon to set up your Canon product.Get started to Canon inkjet setup with guidelines of ij.start.cannonsite.

    ReplyDelete
  12. Really very helpful information. Keep it up! With the essay help of highly skilled professionals, we are offering the best Essay Writing service. If this is what you are looking for, then you are at the right stop. Visit our website and get the best services by professionals at any time.

    ReplyDelete
  13. The Webroot program is highly rated software to protect your devices & data available for download at
    ij.start.canon| ij.start.cannon/ts3322 | Microsoft365.com/setup
    | microsoft365.com/setup

    ReplyDelete
  14. Education is a crucial part of a growing individual. Students undergo a hectic day involving studies, sports and different important co-curricular activities. Within the thick of all the exhausting work, it's sensible to be independent in your own studies Assignment Help as academic qualification and studies do facilitate in obtaining you a job.

    ReplyDelete
  15. Professionals can assist you in creating the finest design for your needs. If you want a less sterile image, use a combination of lights such as pole and bollard lights, as well as a few landscaping lights if your parking lot has planted parts.
    Commercial light pole , Gas station price sign , Neon sign repair

    ReplyDelete
  16. على الرغم من أن طعام القطط عالي الجودة يكلف أكثر ، فإن قطتك ستأكل أقل لأن البروتين أكثر وهو راضٍ من الناحية التغذوية. سوف يستهلك أقل وسيكون أقل عرضة للإصابة بالكبد أو مشاكل أخرى نتيجة لذلك. نتيجة لذلك ، ستوفر المال على فواتير الطبيب البيطري وستحصل على قطة أكثر سعادة وصحة.
    اكل القطط, اكل قطط رويال كانين , للجرب و الديدان لا ينزل في الحليب

    ReplyDelete
  17. When the condition has developed, intravenous antibiotics are used to treat it. Effective in eradicating infection, however because the condition has progressed, symptom recovery takes time.
    lyme disease natural cures , Lyme disease treatment

    ReplyDelete
  18. Many folks are becoming older and moving closer to retirement. All federal programmes and nursing homes are meant to provide the highest possible level of general and medical care.
    skilled nursing facilities near me , in home care near me , Fingerprinting near me

    ReplyDelete
  19. Are you planning a tropical vacation? Visit Costa Rica, a place rich in natural beauty and recreational opportunities! As a prominent tourist destination and one of the most cost-effective tropical vacations. Whether you want to relax on the beach, taste local specialties, see local landmarks, or zip line through a rain forest, this country has it all! Costa Rica is the place to go if you want a relaxing vacation with plenty of sunshine. Warm beaches border the Pacific Ocean's coasts in this Central American country, which offers numerous sandy beaches. Many rental properties near the beaches are also available for guests to rent for the duration of their stay in Costa Rica.
    costa rica vacation homes, costa rica luxury vacation rentals

    ReplyDelete
  20. Research also suggests that when the elderly or those with medical issues leave the hospital and return home, they recover faster. The environment will make the patient feel better, resulting in a faster recovery and better physical and psychological state.
    home care services for elderly , personal home care maryland

    ReplyDelete
  21. In our organization, Connectwise Control is used to provide remote support for internal and general customers when needed. It integrates powerful tools and functions to remotely connect devices, share screens, transfer files, communicate with users through built-in chat, etc. on the same platform. It works perfectly, is easy to install, and does not consume a lot of equipment resources.

    ReplyDelete
  22. Your blog gave us significant data to work with. Each and each tip of your post are amazing. You're the best for sharing. Continue to blog

    ij.start.cannon
    www.office.com/setup
    www.norton.com/setup

    ReplyDelete
  23. skateboard bearings
    Abec 9 Skateboard Bearings Perfect for your Gold Coast Longboards cruiser or Longboard

    ReplyDelete
  24. kitchen designs gold coast
    KBHI offers a complete Kitchen designs and decorating service, managing the whole process from concept through to completion. Our team can assist you with refreshing your kitchen – ie new benchtops, doors, panels and splash or we can design and construct a new kitchen Cabinet space in Gold Coast that caters to your every need.

    ReplyDelete
  25. Hi, I love to see your recent post for expanding the knowledge set as much as I can. We like to see latest work with the proper linking of Online Assignment Help service.

    ReplyDelete
  26. office.com/setup - To Install Office Setup office.com/setup Enter Office Setup Product Key and activate, setup office product, visit Microsoft Office at office.com/setup and Get Started.


    office.com/setup - To get started with your Microsoft Office Installation you need valid product key code & visit www.Office.com/Setup and we can also help you with your entire process to setup office at office.com/setup.


    office.com/setup – To Install Office setup Enter office setup product key and activate, setup office, visit Microsoft office at office.com/setup and Get Installed. - To Install Office Setup office.com/setup Enter Office Setup Product Key and activate, setup office product, visit Microsoft Office at office.com/setup and Get Started.

    ReplyDelete
  27. norton.com/setup - For Downloading, Installing and activating the Norton product, visit Norton Setup and Get Started with Norton Antivirus at www.norton.com/setup. or www.norton.com/setup or norton.com/setup.

    ReplyDelete
  28. mywifiext.net Login
    Facing issues with mywifiext.net login? Unable to set up or install your Netgear WiFi extender?
    Don’t panic! Here, you will get to know everything about setting up your Netgear extender  Netgear Wifi Extender setup.

    mcafee.com/activate Mcafee/setup answer your questions, troubleshoot problems and offer you expert tips for your PC & Website. We are dedicated to helping our PC users with every issue they are facing. We understand your issues and deliver quick problem resolution. Our service can be availed 24/7

    Kashmir tour packages It gives us immense pleasure to introduce ourself and our travel hub one of the premier travel hubs in the state of Jammu Kashmir.


    ReplyDelete
  29. tree stump removal gold coast
    One of the biggest challenges when it comes to stump removal on the Gold Coast is getting rid of the unsightly stump that remains after cutting down the tree. Before trying to remove stumps on your own, consider the following reasons to engage with a professional stump grinding company:

    ReplyDelete
  30. helicopter school melbourne
    Melbourne provides the ultimate in tourism opportunities! Beaches, Parks, Wineries and iconic City views of landmarks such as the Melbourne Cricket Ground (MCG), Luna Park and the Albert Park Lake – home of the Australian Formula 1 Grand Prix.

    ReplyDelete
  31. Established in 1981, PHS offer unequaled training in all areas of helicopter flying from Private Pilot Licence to the most advanced Instrument and Night Vision flying. With over 40 years’ experience in training helicopter pilots PHS should be your first choice.

    ReplyDelete
  32. injectables gold coast
    Cosmetic fillers are a safe and effective way to plump up the skin around your face, where time is taking a toll. They can also be used to reduce the appearance of scars or where skin folds over unnaturally.

    ReplyDelete
  33. promotional merchandise
    There are many options of branded merchandise on the market but not all options are practical or eco-friendly. Contact us with your ideas and we would love to help put together a collection of product that will be loved by everyone!

    ReplyDelete
  34. gold coast digital marketing agency
    SEO is the process of optimising the visibility of a website on search engines, from an organic or unpaid point of view. Using the latest technology and our own in-house Gold Coast agency created checklist will boost your SEO rankings to new levels.

    ReplyDelete
  35. The cannon printer is very useful for home and office to print any type of document.The print has one of the magnificent print resolution.

    ij.start.cannon has two ink cartridges-Black and Color, as your requirement.It is compatible with every major operating system.

    ReplyDelete